Caledonia Dreaming : commitment, literature and independence

Marie-Odile Pittin-Hedon (1)

1 LERMA - Laboratoire d'Etudes et de Recherche sur le Monde Anglophone

This paper examines the notion of commitment in literature in the contemporary context, and the connection between literature and nationalism in Scotland. It starts with the philosophical reflection on the goal of all art that Alan Riach and Alexander Moffat based their argument on in their book The Arts of Independence (2014), in order to underline the ways commitment is related to the history of cultural nationalism and to the representation of Scottish identity in contemporary literature, in places where this representation does appear. In order to do so, the paper tackles the necessity for artists to eschew what Eleanor Bell calls the postmodern predicament, in particular the dangers of an essentialist approach to Scottishness. It also examines the wider implications of the concept of cultural nationalism, in a context where inferiorism as well as banal nationalism are surfacing again. These recent developments have led artists and critics alike to try to devise new configurations for cultural nationalism, with the return of the idea of an " archipelagic " identity, or with a distinction being drawn between independence and interdependence for example. The part played by the artists in the independence debate, their commitment, has been precisely to promote a literature that looks at what, according to Riach and Moffat, is the essential goal and virtue of all art, to speak to and of our humanity.

Mots clés: Independence referendum and literature; Alan Riach; Alexander Moffat; Iain MacWhirter; Ernest Gellner; Angus Calder; Eleanor Bell; banal Nationalism; essentialism; cultural nationalism; postmodern predicament; mongrel nation; Alan Bissett; Ewan Morrison; “Vote Britain”; inferiorism; Alasdair Gray; “Settlers and colonists”; James Robertson; Irvine Welsh.

Domaines: Littératures

Marie-Odile Pittin-Hedon. Caledonia Dreaming : commitment, literature and independence. Observatoire de la société britannique, 2016, 18, pp.129-145. ⟨10.4000/osb.1831⟩. ⟨hal-01310269⟩